The church ladies empty this tray before the potluck even officially starts. You will make these for every gathering using only 4 ingredients.

Use half a ranch packet for a milder flavor
Add a splash of milk to soften the spread
Swap in vegetable or chive cream cheese
Try a mix of white and whole wheat bread for contrast

❄️ Storage & Make-Ahead

Refrigerate up to 24 hours (best within a few hours)
Store between wax paper layers in an airtight container
Keep chilled until serving
Do not leave out more than 2 hours

❤️ Final Note

These sandwiches don’t try to impress—but they always do.
Soft bread, creamy filling, crisp cucumber—it’s the kind of simple combination that just works.

And just like at every good potluck…
don’t be surprised if they’re the first thing gone.